Vivek Agnihotri is known for creating movies that push boundaries and spark debates. From The Kashmir Files to The Bengal Files, his films often tackle sensitive historical and political topics, resulting in both acclaim and backlash, making him one of the most controversial directors in Indian cinema. Whether it’s addressing tragedies, questioning history, or challenging political ideologies, his work continues to ignite strong reactions across audiences.
The Kashmir Files
This movie was based on the tragic departure of Kashmiri Pandits from the Kashmir Valley during the 1990s. Although it was praised for highlighting a difficult chapter in Indian history, it faced intense backlash for allegedly spreading hatred and having a political agenda.
The Bengal Files
Vivek Agnihotri’s up-to-date movie focuses on the political and communal strife in Bengal during the 1940s. Even prior to its launch, the movie encountered multiple criticisms. A legal petition was submitted by the relatives of freedom fighter Gopal Mukherjee, claiming the film misrepresents historical truths. The film faced challenges with early ticket sales and censorship problems abroad.
The Tashkent Files
This political thriller explored the mysterious death of ex-Prime Minister Lal Bahadur Shastri. Some praised the film for its boldness in challenging official narratives, while others criticised it for supposedly distorting facts and endorsing conspiracy theories.
Buddha In A Traffic Jam
This socio-political drama explored themes such as corruption, naxalism, and politics in academia. It was at the centre of massive protests, especially at universities and colleges, where screenings were disrupted due to its political messaging.
Hate Story
As the creator of this daring thriller, Vivek Agnihotri encountered backlash for the film’s explicit content. Hate Story ignited discussions regarding the boundaries of sexuality in Indian film. While it achieved commercial success, it faced controversy for its depiction of revenge and allure.
Chocolate
This action thriller sparked debate due to its strong influence from Hollywood movies, particularly The Usual Suspects. Critics accused the movie of plagiarism, and it became a talking point for the lack of originality in Bollywood at the time. Although it wasn’t politically charged, it nonetheless sparked discussions within the film community.
The Delhi Files
Rumoured to be the final installment in Vivek Agnihotri’s Files Trilogy, this new film has already sparked excitement and debate. Though the exact storyline hasn’t been revealed, it is expected to discount with another politically sensitive historical event. Many people are expecting discussions and intense debates even before its release.
Final thoughts
Vivek Agnihotri has established himself as a filmmaker who challenges mainstream narratives and sparks nationwide debates. From The Kashmir Files to The Bengal Files, his films frequently delve into delicate political and historical subjects, resulting in both praise and backlash. Although his storytelling has been praised for its daring nature, it has also encountered criticism for supposed biases and inaccuracies.
